Episode 118 Review - "Gem of a Different Color"




PLOT A:  Fishlegs rides the Crazy Train….I mean, Fishlegs finds his Bravery

Fishlegs is tired of being pushed around by Snotlout, and when he feels he’s to blame for the separation of un-hatched changewings eggs from their mother’s, he’ll do ANYTHING to get them back to their rightful place.

This was quite an interesting plot in description. With Fishlegs’ skittish and over nervous personality it was pretty much impossible to avoid him learning to stand up for himself in one of these episodes.

In this episode, Fishlegs was protective of un-hatched baby dragons, wanting nothing more than to get them back to their mothers after realizing he took an egg himself. And—with Fishlegs being so obsessed with dragons—this was kind of the perfect way to avoid being too predictable but still being in character.

Most “side characters find their bravery” episodes are when the count is down, the main character is in some kind of peril, and usually the “scared sidekick” finally steps up and saves the day. Luckily, this episode wasn’t that “textbook standard” bravery episode. Hiccup, the main character, wasn’t down for the count, he was helpful, but it was still not too odd that it was more about Fishlegs. I like that he stepped up and took responsibility all on his own just because it was something he so heavily believed in.

So…I liked this plot. It was reasonable and did its job. I also like that they had Fishlegs go completely crazy for a few minutes (another callback to the book series). He wasn’t just the justified noble guy…he went crazy and scared the crap out of even Snotlout.

It was funny when Mulch said “it’s always the quiet ones to snap the loudest”…and Fishlegs’ rant did go down the list of his pinned up annoyances, especially when he said “you can mock my impressive dragon knowledge”.

It did run a bit on the overkill or corny side once or twice sometimes in the lines and lines delivery, but hey…can’t be perfect.

So…Solid plot that did its job is solid…



PLOT B: Good luck Sucks Rocks

The eggs Fishlegs found are said to be “good luck stones” and of course everyone wants them…especially Snotlout, who can launch his “get rich quick” scheme as soon as he finds a huge stash.

Very rarely can the reactions of the other characters make a functional plot…but in this case it kind of does. Despite this being a Fishlegs episode, Snotlout played a big role as well….

I did initially have some slight problems with Snotlout, though.

It’s no surprise that he’s still a huge jerk…but some of the stuff he said just seemed so…soulless and petty and I know he’s at least a tad better than that, especially after the crack in the surface of his character growth in episode 116. But when you analyze a character like Snotlout you realize that he’s just an opportunist…and an insecure on at that, so his actions to fit to a certain degree.

Still….He was pretty much the Mildew of the episode—in which he was that annoying character you just wanna slap cause they’re just…ugh…go home!

I’m not really sure how much of a lesson he learned in this episode. He backed off when Fishlegs went berserk on him (Fishlegs must have learned that from watching Dagur), but at the ending he seemed pretty fired up. At this point I would like to see Snotlout’s attitude improving just a hair…a drastic change would be unrealistic, but some subtle differences in choices of actions over the rest of the show would be a treat. 
Maybe it’ll start next season…?

Luckily—or unluckily—his rather inhuman negligence was softened a bit to watch by Gustav! He’s so adorable, and the first child to speak on the show (or the franchise…) since the little girl in episode 106 who wanted her Lamby back.

Gustav seems to be at that impressionable age where he sees the big and “cool” Viking in Snotlout and wants to copy him and repeat what he says. He should probably get a better role model though….But seeing as how his own mother sold him for a good luck stone, I can see why his role model choices are questionable.

But, for every questionable character move….there’s a good one. And I love how this show has subtly built up the friendship between Hiccup, Astrid, and Fishlegs and continued to show it. In the later episodes, it’s very easy to catch that the group of six is broke up into two sub-groups within one. Tuffnut, Ruffnut, and Snotlout…and Fishlegs, Hiccup, and Astrid.

Fishlegs, Hiccup, and Astrid seem to know that, out of the group, they can rely on each other. This was proven in the last episode as well, when Hiccup only choose Astrid and Fishlegs to go with him…and now Fishlegs choose Hiccup and Astrid to go with him to return the dragon eggs, as well as they’re constantly the only ones who went to console him. Nice development there. Very nice! That kind of subtle development is the kind Snotlout needs….



PLOT C: Changewings…….That’s about it.

A group of wild changewings are angered and come raging through Berk to retrieve the eggs Snotlout has taken from them.

Changewings seemed to be the number two dragon everyone wanted to see. (What’s number two? The Skrill, of course.) But I can say that this plot seemed a little too much like a callback to episode 104 (Terrible Twos).  As in, angry mother dragon is a threat cause they want their baby. Only this time—and thankfully because it makes for a difference—the mothers actually came to Berk and messed stuff up…not just in the forest.

I applaud “new dragon” episodes like 109, 114, and 117 for they break the norm when it comes to “threatening dragons”, but this one seemed a tad redundant to me despite the fact that the dragons were awesome (but this plot get’s “cool” points cause…they were awesome!).

Also…the biggest “oops” moment in this episode (and perhaps the season) was the fact that there was said to be no picture of a changewing in the Book of Dragons….yet in the movie there’s clearly a picture. Someone who hasn’t watched the movie, obviously, won’t catch that. Still….that was just…nope. There’s really nothing I can say to excuse it. That was an “um…did you watch the movie?” moment, for sure. But then, it’s not really surprising that this show leans more towards the “convenient” than that practical sometimes.

Forgetfulness and redundancy aside, like I said, changewings are cool!!! It was the best to see the final act where the changewing chaos was occurring, because it’s funny to fight something you can’t see. And extra points for the funny Tuffnut “forbidden friendship (with a rock)” moment. Classic Tuffnut comedy can make anything better!

So…the dragons are cool…but the plot can be worked on to be a bit more spicy.



FINAL THOUGHTS:

So this episode had some innovative stuff, some questionable stuff, some good stuff, and some stuff with some spots of mildew on it…

It was a bit of a mixed bag….but had enough of that “underdog” likability to the plot and ending that saved it from getting a weird grade.

Animation was good as well….even if Hiccup’s hair did that weird growing and shrinking every other scene thing again.

Though the pacing was kind of iffy as well. It pulled a first half of the season move and presented a good first act set up…lollygagged around in the second act…and then kind of rushed through the third act to make up for time. So, that weakened it a bit.

Although I would like to mention—in favor—that the second half of the season impresses me with how much they callback to past events, both in the movie in the show (ironically since this same episode also made a big mistake as well in that same area). But, nonetheless, having Ruffnut mention Tuffnut’s run in with fireworms in episode 108 was a nice touch. Because I remember in the first half of the season it almost seemed like each previous episodes never happened…cause it was never brought up again.

And…who liked Hiccup’s two seconds of fighting skills before Astrid kicked his butt? I know I enjoyed it. (Of course that might just be because I’m a *gasp* Hiccstrid shipper!)

But still…as far as episodes used to develop a minor character go…this one was pretty solid. It had some speed bumps, but it was a fun ride….and we all know we clapped for Fishlegs so don’t even deny it.


Previous || Next
                                                            Breakneck Bog || We are Family, Part 1